Sunday, Jul 15th

Last updateThu, 12 Jul 2018 2pm

You are here: Home Content Neighborhood News Court Dismisses Article 78 Filed by Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
Where are the Kindergartners? School District Experiencing Enrollment Dip

Where are the Kindergartners? School District Experiencing Enrollment Dip

If current trends hold, the Scarsdale School district may have the ...

Historic Mid-century Home is Back on the Market in Fox Meadow

Historic Mid-century Home is Back on the Market in Fox Meadow

(Updated July 11, 2018)  After being denied permission to tear...

Police Report: Accidents Abound: Camp Bus Hit Head-on; Motorcyclist Knocked from Bike; Car Strikes Fox Meadow Road Garage

Police Report: Accidents Abound: Camp Bus Hit Head-on; Motorcyclist Knocked from Bike; Car Strikes Fox Meadow Road Garage

Collision of a car and a bus on Fenimore Road on Friday

On July 6, a...

Changing of the Guard at Fox Meadow School

Changing of the Guard at Fox Meadow School

The Scarsdale School District is wasting no time filling two unexpe...

SHS Seniors Embark On Paths Less Traveled

SHS Seniors Embark On Paths Less Traveled

“Four years of high school and four years of college” is the formul...

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Court Dismisses Article 78 Filed by Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments

countycourthouseThe long awaited decision by the court on the Article 78 proceeding filed in January 2017 by the Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments is in: Judge Bruce Tolbert of the Supreme Court of the State of New York denied the Article 78 in its entirety and granted the motion to dismiss.

The Article 78 asked the court to annul, void and rescind the 2016 tax assessment roll for Scarsdale and roll back valuations to 2015 assessments. If the Village failed to roll back the assessments, they asked that the petitioners who would pay more taxes on the 2016 roll than the 2015 roll be refunded the difference.

In April 2017 another group of Scarsdale residents filed a motion to intervene to "correct the false record put forth by the Committee and make clear that "all other taxpayers in the Town/Village of Scarsdale" do not agree that the Committee represents their interests." In fact, the motion says that the intervenors "Object to the Village wasting its time and money defending the Article 78" and also "Object to the prospect of Scarsdale's tax assessment procedure being dictated by a judicial monitor rather than proceeding under the established municipal and state regulatory procedures and administrative remedies that govern residential property tax assessments."

Kevin Reed, one of the attorneys who filed the motion to intervene said, "Our clients filed their motion to intervene in the Article 78 proceeding to make clear to the Court that the self-appointed Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments does not represent all Scarsdale taxpayers. If the motion is granted, our clients will advocate to the Court that that the Article 78 proceeding is without merit, that a rollback of the 2016 assessment would cause the Village more harm than good, and that grievances with the results of the 2016 assessment should be pursued on an individual basis through the administrative and judicial mechanisms provided by New York State law."

In the decision dated 1/5/2018, the court rejected the Committee's Article 78 petition on every front. Most importantly, the court dismissed the Committee's central argument—that the Ryan Revaluation was fundamentally flawed and unfair—holding that the challenge to the Ryan Revaluation was "false[]" and based only on a "vague argument" that amounted to an "idea that 'we liked the first one better.'" The decision says, "There is a lack of substance and empirical data by what is presented by the movant in this matter. Clearly, there is a need of sound theory and objective data which is necessary to overcome the presumption regarding the validity of the challenged assessment."

The court found that the committee lacked standing to plead as they are not "a person or a corporation who is a taxpayer." The decision says, "this formed committee, the Scarsdale Committee for Fair Assessments, is not a property owner in its own right, nor is it an incorporated entity."

The court also noted that a full-scale roll-back to the Tyler Revaluation would cause "chaos" and "disrupt[ion]" to the Village. The Committee's Equal Protection claim was rejected for the simple reason that "all of the residents of Scarsdale were treated the same" as they were all subject to the same, valid revaluation.

At a more basic level, the court questioned why the Committee chose to proceed through an Article 78 proceeding rather than individual grievances, as many individual Scarsdale residents do every year. This point was reinforced by the intervenors who volunteered to participate in the action on the side of the Village. The court noted that some of the intervenors "saw a raise in their real estate taxes with the 2016 assessment," and "some have sought Article 7 relief as well." The court observed that this stood in contrast to the Committee, whose members could have sought individual relief but instead chose to seek a full-scale roll-back, which was "clearly against any public policy agenda of any municipality including Scarsdale."

Commenting on the dismissal, Scarsdale Village Attorney Wayne Essanason said, "The decision speaks for itself."

You can read the entire decision here

The Committee has 30 days to choose to appeal this decision.

Good Work

SETTING

Historic Mid-century Home is Back on the Market in Fox Meadow

Historic Mid-century Home is Back on the Market in Fox Meadow

(Updated July 11, 2018)  After being denied permission to tear it down, the owners of a Mid-century Modern home at 8 Overlook Road i...

Read More

Around Town

SETTING

Gun and Vape Shops: Should They Be Permitted in Scarsdale? And If So, Where?

Gun and Vape Shops: Should They Be Permitted in Scarsdale? And If So, Where?

The Law Committee on the Board of Trustees met on Tuesday to deliberate on proposed changes to the zoning of gun and vape shops in Scarsd...

Read More

Neighborhood News

SETTING

SHS Seniors Embark On Paths Less Traveled

SHS Seniors Embark On Paths Less Traveled

“Four years of high school and four years of college” is the formula for success for the vast majority of Scarsdale High School alumni. H...

Read More

On Our Minds

SETTING

Congresssman Engel's Comments on the Nomination of Brett Kavanaugh

Congresssman Engel's Comments on the Nomination of Brett Kavanaugh

Eliot Engel On Monday, President Trump announced that he had selected Brett Kavanaugh as his nominee to replace Justice Anthony Kennedy on...

Read More

On Our Radar

SETTING

Library Loft Now Open to the Community

Library Loft Now Open to the Community

The Scarsdale Library Loft is now open for business! July 5th marked the opening of the new library space located at the Supply Field, 24...

Read More

Parenting

SETTING

Families Cool Off at the Scarsdale Pool on the 4th of July

Families Cool Off at the Scarsdale Pool on the 4th of July

Many Scarsdalians spent this July 4th taking in the sun and cooling off at the Scarsdale Municipal Pool. The pool was packed, with kids a...

Read More

Village Voices

SETTING

BOT Updates Residents on Village Affairs: Sidewalk Sale July 26-28

BOT Updates Residents on Village Affairs: Sidewalk Sale July 26-28

During a relatively short meeting this Tuesday, the mayor and trustees made note of completed projects, such as the opening of he Library...

Read More

Shout it Out

SETTING

Arthur Manor Holds 90th Annual 4th of July Parade and Picnic

Arthur Manor Holds 90th Annual 4th of July Parade and Picnic

During a beautiful, sun-filled and very hot summer day, the Arthur Manor Neighborhood Association held its 90th Annual 4th of July parade...

Read More

School News

SETTING

Board of Ed Elects New Leaders and Approves Synthetic Turf for Butler Field

Board of Ed Elects New Leaders and Approves Synthetic Turf for Butler Field

The 2018-19 Board of Education: Left to Right: Bill Natbony, Alison Singer, Nina Cannon, Scott Silberfein, Chris Morin, Pam Fuehrer and L...

Read More

Schools

SETTING

Where are the Kindergartners? School District Experiencing Enrollment Dip

Where are the Kindergartners? School District Experiencing Enrollment Dip

If current trends hold, the Scarsdale School district may have the lowest enrollment in the last ten years when school opens in September...

Read More

The Goods

SETTING

Lulu's Cake Boutique Creates Life-Sized Replica of Marilyn Monroe

Lulu's Cake Boutique Creates Life-Sized Replica of Marilyn Monroe

Lulu¹s of Scarsdale was recently called on to create the centerfold for this year¹s Edible Hudson Valley #Foodporn themed edition. Never ...

Read More

Real Estate

SETTING

Home Sales: Scarsdale Welcomes Many Newcomers

Home Sales: Scarsdale Welcomes Many Newcomers

Though the home sales market was slow this spring, it looks like activity may be picking up.
This week there are nine homes sold, and hope...

Read More

Today's News

SETTING

Police Report: Accidents Abound: Camp Bus Hit Head-on; Motorcyclist Knocked from Bike; Car Strikes Fox Meadow Road Garage

Police Report: Accidents Abound: Camp Bus Hit Head-on; Motorcyclist Knocked from Bike; Car Strikes Fox Meadow Road Garage

Collision of a car and a bus on Fenimore Road on Friday

On July 6, a bus carrying children from Camp Mohawk was involved in a traffic acci...

Read More

Arts and Entertainment

SETTING

African Music Star to Come to Scarsdale to Benefit SALT at Scarsdale Congregational Church

African Music Star to Come to Scarsdale to Benefit SALT at Scarsdale Congregational Church

International Afro Dance Hall star and Nigerian native Lamboginny will preach and sing at Scarsdale Congregational Church at 10am on Sund...

Read More

People

SETTING

Changing of the Guard at Fox Meadow School

Changing of the Guard at Fox Meadow School

The Scarsdale School District is wasting no time filling two unexpected vacancies at Fox Meadow Elementary School.

In June, both Principal...

Read More

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

Programs for Scarsdale Kids