Monday, Oct 23rd

Last updateMon, 23 Oct 2017 6pm

You are here: Home Parenting League Asks for More Democratic Bond Planning Process
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop
first
  
last
 
 
start
stop

League Asks for More Democratic Bond Planning Process

timeimageThis statement was read to the Board of Education at their September 25, 2017 meeting by Mary Beth Evans, Chair, LWVS School Bond Study Committee, and Linda Doucette-Ashman, Co-President, LWVS and sent to Scarsdale10583 for publication:

To the Board of Education:

The League of Women Voters has been dedicated since its founding in 1921 to the ideals of the democratic process. As a nonpartisan political organization whose core mission is to promote the informed and active participation of citizens in government, the League of Women Voters of Scarsdale has a long history of studying and commenting on local government engagement of community input into the decision making process.

While not without precedent, it is unusual for the League of Women Voters of Scarsdale Board of Directors ("League Board") to issue statements in advance of a League member consensus meeting; however, after discussion, we determined that the following major concerns about the current School District facilities bond process do warrant a League Board statement at this time:

• The School District has made available to the public an extraordinarily large volume of data during six public meetings over the past four months; yet, this information has neither been presented in a digestible format, nor has it remained constant, with plans and priorities, and even the numerical ranking and definition of priority work items, subject to change from meeting to meeting.

• At the same time, the community has yet to be provided with a framework for understanding what our school buildings need in order to preserve and enhance a high quality Scarsdale education.

• The community also has not been provided a clear statement of the School Board's overall objective for this bond as it relates to the quality of our schools and Scarsdale educational values.

• Meanwhile, major bond related decisions have already been made over the summer with insufficient opportunity for public input and insufficient School Board deliberation to fully inform the public in a manner that allows the community to engage, question, challenge and/or support the School Board's educational rationale and fiscal assumptions.

• In addition, a compressed schedule of School Board-directed building and District-wide committee meetings, which did not begin until this month, does not allow sufficient time for the School Board to consider and respond to possible committee recommendations for substantive changes to either the proposed Greenacres School renovation and addition plan or the proposed uses for the remainder of the bond before the October 16 statutory deadline to issue a final bond resolution for a December 2017 bond vote.

• Moreover, given the short amount of time and the absence of School Board meetings between now and October 16, members of the community may reasonably assume that there is no opportunity to significantly modify either the Greenacres School proposal or the proposed uses for the remainder of the bond.

• Finally, although the public was told back in May that there would be a "full blown bond package" and public "forums" in September, a "December 2017 bond vote" timeline now appears to be driving a process that does not allow time for the community to weigh in on a complete bond package before the School Board would need to adopt a final bond resolution.

The League Board maintains that rather than allowing a goal of a particular bond vote date to determine the extent of community participation, a goal of maximum community engagement and input into the bond decision-making process should be a School Board priority in deciding the bond timeline.

In order to develop a school bond that is a product of a District-community partnership, the School Board should proactively encourage such partnership by ensuring the final bond proposal accurately reflects community values and priorities. We further maintain that regardless of the extent of community input since the start of the bond process in 2014, the community has not had sufficient opportunity to weigh in on whether the current iteration of the proposal released to the public September 11 accurately reflects community values.

We also note that as elected officials accountable to the public, members of the School Board should allow themselves time to deliberate fully and openly on all aspects of the bond proposal in order to give the public both insight into their decision-making process and opportunity to weigh in on their deliberations.

We therefore recommend that the School Board:

1) Set a bond vote date that prioritizes community participation, allows for a more deliberative School Board process, and involves the School Board's proactive engagement of the community's input; and
2) Immediately address issues of community engagement by adding multiple dedicated meetings for public presentations and community feedback to ensure the School Board's final decision is guided by community values and priorities.

Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely,

Linda Doucette-Ashman and Janice Starr, Co-Presidents
Mary Beth Evans, Chair, School Bond Study Committee
League of Women Voters of Scarsdale

Click here to see additional questions from the LWVS raised at the 9-11-17 meeting of the Board of Education.

Comments   

+7 #7 Update please 2017-09-27 18:11
Is there a way to find out if the LWVS questions have been answered? I think their questions have been very thoughtful.

Thank you
Quote
-8 #6 M. Smith 2017-09-27 13:46
Yes, the League works hard, but the members have very select interests. They want a new Greenacres school so they are criticizing the Board of Ed right now. They were pro-library so they worked on that. Where were they when the Mandarin and Ryan reval topics were hot? Quoting Thank you:
Thank you to the LWVS for looking out for the community. If it ever feels that your work is thankless, please know that many people are truly appreciative of you efforts.
Quote
+13 #5 Thank you 2017-09-27 12:18
Thank you to the LWVS for looking out for the community. If it ever feels that your work is thankless, please know that many people are truly appreciative of you efforts.
Quote
+9 #4 M. Smith 2017-09-27 11:17
The League is only one community voice. As much as the League members are doing, they cannot do it alone. There are also the PTAs, the Education Committee of the Scarsdale Forum and individual residents. If we just write in these pages, that will not mobilize people. Elections or referenda are not won in blogs or social media. Quoting Resident:
The big question is whether the Leagur will do anything about the fact that they are being ignored by this board and administration. Will they actually oppose the bond?
Quote
+8 #3 Resident 2017-09-26 21:49
The big question is whether the Leagur will do anything about the fact that they are being ignored by this board and administration. Will they actually oppose the bond?
Quote
+16 #2 M. Smith 2017-09-26 18:30
Congratulations , League of Women Voters. Is this the third set of questions and suggestions that you send since June? Have any of your letters been answered by Dr. Hagerman and the administration? Your persistence is admirable. I hope that Scarsdale residents are noticing that your good efforts are being ignored by the Administration.
Quote
+14 #1 Scarsdale Resident 2017-09-26 13:28
Has anyone else noticed that the District has stopped posting minutes of the Greenacres Building and Districtwide Committees on their website? No updates for two weeks. So much for transparency.
Quote

Add comment

first
  
last
 
 
start
stop